Saturday, March 8, 2008
Obama's Irish aide quits after calling Clinton a 'monster'
former adviser to Barack Obama who resigned Friday after calling rival Hillary Rodham Clinton "a monster" said Obama may not be able to withdraw all U.S. combat troops from Iraq within a year as he has promised on the campaign trail.
Samantha Power, a Pulitzer Prize-winner author and unpaid adviser, made the comments in two separate interviews with foreign media while promoting her latest book. In a tight Democratic presidential campaign where attacks are becoming increasingly bitter, Power's comments ignited a flurry of accusations between the two candidates.
Clinton said it's hard to know what Obama's real positions are, while Obama insisted he will end the war in 2009 if elected and blamed Clinton for helping start it.
The comment that led to Power's resignation came in an interview with The Scotsman. "She is a monster, too _ that is off the record _ she is stooping to anything," the newspaper quoted her as saying. A few hours after the comments were published, Power, a Harvard professor, announced her resignation in a statement in which she said the remarks were inexcusable and contradictory to her admiration for Clinton.
Power told RTE, Ireland's public broadcast service, that she spoke with Obama by phone Friday and he "made it absolutely clear that we just couldn't make comments like this in his campaign."
Clinton's campaign sent an e-mail to supporters telling them about the monster comment and asking for contributions to "show the Obama campaign that there is a price to this kind of attack politics."
Power's comments about Iraq came in an interview with the BBC. She said Obama's position is that withdrawing all U.S. troops within 16 months is a "best-case scenario" that he will revisit if he becomes president.
"He will, of course, not rely on some plan that he's crafted as a presidential candidate or a U.S. senator," she said. "He will rely upon a plan _ an operational plan _ that he pulls together in consultation with people who are on the ground to whom he doesn't have daily access now, as a result of not being the president."
Obama has actually shortened his original 16-month commitment to say he'll end the war in 2009. Obama advisers say President Bush's plan to draw troops down to 15 brigades this year means Obama could complete the removal in a year.
In Mississippi, Clinton questioned the Iraq comments based on Obama's public statements.
"He has attacked me continuously for having no hard exit date, and now we learn he doesn't have one, in fact he doesn't have a plan at all," Clinton told reporters.
Obama told voters in Casper, Wyo., that Clinton has no standing to question his resolve because she voted in 2002 to authorize the war.
"If it had been up to me, we would have never been in this war," Obama said, his voice rising. "It was because of George Bush, with an assist from Hillary Clinton and John McCain, that we got into this war.
"I will end it in 2009," he said. "She doesn't have standing to question my position on this issue."
Power's resignation came a day after Clinton spokesman Howard Wolfson compared Obama to former special prosecutor Kenneth Starr by criticizing Clinton. Starr's investigation led to Bill Clinton's impeachment, and he is an unpopular figure among Democratic voters.
"I for one do not believe that imitating Ken Starr is the way to win a Democratic primary election for president," Wolfson said.
Clinton told reporters Wolfson's criticism was different from the monster description because "one is an ad hominem attack and one is a historical reference."
She also said Wolfson's criticism "is a true statement."
With a sparkling intellect, a mane of auburn hair and a Pulitzer Prize-winning book to her credit, Samantha Power cut a disarming path just about anywhere she went.
Power's ebullient style won over many journalists, diplomats and one presidential contender. But outspokenness became her undoing, forcing Power on Friday to quit Illinois Sen. Barack Obama's presidential campaign after publication of an interview in which she called his Democratic rival, New York Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton, "a monster."
The 37-year-old Harvard professor and Time magazine columnist gave up her position as a foreign policy advisor to Obama and apologized for describing Clinton in "such negative and personal terms."
But that was not the only Power-related trouble for Obama. Comments about his Iraq stance that she made earlier during an overseas book tour forced Obama on Friday to repeat to the public that if elected he would withdraw troops from Iraq and "bring this war to an end in 2009."
At the end of another day of distraction for his presidential campaign, Obama had lost one of his earliest, and certainly most charismatic, advisors. And Power saw her comments open a new line of attack for Clinton.
Experts said she might have lost her way at the fuzzy intersection of her roles as author, journalist and campaign operative. "If you are a book writer promoting yourself and your work, you are supposed to be provocative and interesting and tell the truth," said Tom Rosenstiel, director of the Project for Excellence in Journalism. "Candidates are not there to speak the truth in all of its glory. They are there to win an election."
The Power contretemps came just a week after another controversy erupted over whether Obama's top economic advisor had told Canadian officials that Obama did not fully embrace his own attacks on the North American Free Trade Agreement.
The missteps distracted from the candidate's effort to regain momentum after losing primaries Tuesday in Ohio, Texas and Rhode Island.
"The problem for them is having a couple of these missteps at exactly the wrong time," said Joe Trippi, who was a top strategist former Sen. John Edwards' now-defunct presidential campaign. Although he called attacks by Clinton on Obama's foreign policy experience "unfair," Trippi added: "It's not a good thing to have one of your leading foreign policy proponents saying things that you have to back away from or explain."
Obama and his erstwhile advisor met in 2005, after he became intrigued by her prize-winning "A Problem From Hell: America and the Age of Genocide." The two talked late into the night at a steakhouse, much of the conversation centering on her belief that the United States should have done more to stop the devastating killing in Darfur and other places.
If Obama has been dubbed the "rock star" candidate, Power might have been his rock star advisor. Born in Ireland and schooled at Yale and Harvard Law, she was founding executive director of the Carr Center for Human Rights Policy at Harvard. The Times of London said she would have fit right in with the Kennedy clan. She once played basketball with actor George Clooney, a fellow Darfur activist.
A member of Obama's inner circle, Power was an unpaid advisor. She had previously confided to friends that she had ambitions to one day be secretary of State.
Her troubles began when she traveled to Britain to promote her latest book, "Chasing the Flame: Sergio Vieira de Mello and the Fight to Save the World," a biography of the dashing U.N. envoy killed at U.N. headquarters in Baghdad in 2003.
In a freewheeling interview conducted by the Scotsman newspaper, Power used an expletive to say the Obama campaign had blown the recent primary in Ohio. She suggested voters there had become "obsessed" with the economy and said Clinton had played on those concerns.
"She is a monster, too -- that is off the record -- she is stooping to anything," Power told political correspondent Gerri Peev. She added of Clinton: "The amount of deceit she has put forward is really unattractive."
Peev followed a standard journalistic practice in requiring interview subjects -- particularly political operatives -- to reach agreement in advance if they want to keep matters out of the public domain.
Peev said in an interview Friday that she found Power "intelligent and likable" but that "it would be a disservice and dereliction of duty if I didn't run the quotes I have on my tape recorder."
Power said in a statement: "I made inexcusable remarks that are at marked variance from my oft-stated admiration for Sen. Clinton and from the spirit, tenor and purpose of the Obama campaign. And I extend my deepest apologies to Sen. Clinton, Sen. Obama and the remarkable team I have worked with over these long 14 months."
In a subsequent interview with the Boston Globe, Power said she had been tired from an overnight flight and disturbed by news she received by phone during the interview about Clinton campaign tactics.
"I care passionately -- obviously, too passionately -- about the Obama campaign," Power told the Globe, adding that she had resigned to remove "all the distractions that I had brought."
The distractions did not end immediately, however.
The Clinton campaign on Friday helped publicize the fact that Power also appeared to soft-pedal Obama's stated plan to bring all troops home from Iraq within 16 months.
Pressed by an interviewer on the BBC’s “Hardtalk” program, Power said: "You can't make a commitment in March 2008 about what circumstances will be like in January of 2009," adding that the Obama plan was a "best-case scenario" that he "will revisit when he becomes president."
That led to a tit-for-tat on the campaign trail Friday, with Clinton saying in Hattiesburg, Miss., that the episode "raises disturbing questions about what the real planning and policy positions inside the Obama campaign happen to be," and Obama responding from Casper, Wyo., that he would withdraw from Iraq by next year.
Yet another Power zinger, delivered in an interview with a British magazine, did not get much notice Friday.